Audience Audit

Custom segmentation solutions for smart agencies and their clients.

Turns Out: Pay less for hours, more for judgment

By Leave a Comment

September 2026  ·  Issue 2
Turns out “reduce fees for us” is the second-to-last thing your clients want from your use of AI.
The Agency Edge is our annual study of the people who hire agencies — this year, 400 of them buying from small-to-mid-sized marketing shops. We group them by what they believe rather than by industry or budget, and three client mindsets came back. All three want the same thing from AI, and a discount is nowhere near the top of the list.
The three client mindsets
Performance Pragmatists, 37%. The largest client group, and the results-first wing. 80% say strong performance results matter more than how an agency achieves them, against 63% of clients overall.
Strategic Stewards, 32%. The partnership wing. 95% look to their agency to help them anticipate change rather than react to it, against 83% overall, and they over-index on every trust signal in the study.
Adaptive Accelerators, 32%. The AI-forward wing. 87% say using AI tools effectively is now a core expectation for any agency, against 70% overall.

What you would expect, from the way this industry talks about AI, is one direction of travel on money: the work gets faster, so the fee comes down, and the only argument left is how far.

What the data says is that cutting your fee is close to the last thing they are asking for. What they want more of is your thinking.

Two bars comparing agency client agreement: 82 percent are willing to pay more for specialized expertise; 51 percent expect fees to decrease if AI reduces the time a job takes.

Read that 51% carefully, because it is conditional. Clients expect the fee to fall if AI reduces the time a job takes — which only bites you if time is what you sold them. AI visibly makes hours cheaper and your clients can see that as plainly as you can. What it does not touch is judgment.

And when you ask them directly, hours are not what they are asking about. Asked what they expect their agencies to do because of AI, clients put better effectiveness, better strategy and better ideas at the top, each at 52%. “Reduce fees for us” came in at 29%, sixteenth out of twenty options.

And the clients most likely to walk are already sorted. 42% of clients expect to reduce their reliance on agencies in favor of AI tools they can run themselves. Among Strategic Stewards it is 11%.

The clients leaving with the software are largely the ones who were already treating you as a supplier, and the Strategic Stewards who treat you as an advisor are not only staying, they are the readiest of anyone to pay a premium — 87%, against 82% of clients overall.

 
Susan’s Take

If you bill for time, AI is coming for your rate card, and half your clients have said so. I would not fight that one — I would stop selling time.

There are two versions of that move. If you sell hours, start selling the thinking those hours were always buying. If you sell projects, lead on the judgment inside them rather than the speed or the production — speed and production are precisely what your client can now buy somewhere else.

What nobody should be doing is cutting their fees. That answers a question most of your clients never asked, and it makes the premium the other 82% will pay a great deal harder to hold.

What those clients are buying is what they get because you use AI — the sharper strategy, the idea they could not have reached on their own, the judgment about which of the fifty generated options is the right one.

If your proposals still price effort, three things worth trying before the next one goes out:

  • Count the lines in your last proposal that describe effort rather than outcome. Those are the ones a client can benchmark against software.
  • Write down the single decision in that project the client could not have reached without you. That is what you were actually selling, and it is usually nowhere in the document.
  • Ask your team what happens to the price if the work takes half as long. If the number drops, you are still selling hours.

Change one of those before the next proposal rather than all three.
See the research
Two minutes: what do your clients actually want from you? Compare your instincts with 400 of them.
Susan

I write with AI as my co-author. The ideas, the advice and the final read are mine.

Get the next one

One surprising finding from our research, every couple of weeks. If a study turns up nothing that contradicts what agency leaders already assume, we skip the issue.

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *