Turns Out: What clients think you’re worth

October 2026  ·  Issue 4
Turns out the thing agency leaders most fear is the opposite of how clients are feeling.
46% of agency leaders name the impact of AI on their relevance as a pressing challenge, and half name getting clients to pay them what they are worth. So we asked 400 people who actually hire agencies what an agency is worth to them.
The three client mindsets
Performance Pragmatists, 37%. The largest client group, and the results-first wing. 80% say strong performance results matter more than how an agency achieves them, against 63% of clients overall.
Strategic Stewards, 32%. The partnership wing. 95% look to their agency to help them anticipate change rather than react to it, against 83% overall.
Adaptive Accelerators, 32%. The AI-forward wing. 87% say using AI tools effectively is now a core expectation for any agency, against 70% overall.

What you would expect, if you have been reading the industry commentary, is a client base quietly reconsidering whether agencies are worth the money.

What the data says is the opposite, and by a wide margin.

Agency clients asked how working with an agency affects the likelihood of achieving their goals over the next two years: 50 percent say it will greatly increase it, 42 percent somewhat increase it, 5 percent no effect, 2 percent somewhat decrease it, 2 percent not sure.

Nine in ten clients say working with an agency makes them more likely to hit their goals over the next two years. Three-quarters call a marketing agency a critical partner for business success. Among Strategic Stewards that rises to 83%.

Meanwhile the profession that produced those numbers spends a good deal of its time wondering whether it still matters.

One caveat: these clients already buy agency services, so they are not a jury on whether agencies in general are worth it. What they do settle is the premise. The fear is that the category has lost its value in clients’ eyes, and the clients say otherwise — clearly, and hardest in the segment that spends the most.

Susan’s Take

A worry this size, and this wrong, is expensive. It shows up as apologetic pricing, as scope thrown in to keep somebody happy, as pitches that open with reassurance instead of a point of view.

What they actually complain about is legibility. They often cannot tell what they are getting for the money — a much smaller problem than the one this industry has been bracing for, and one you can fix this quarter.

The cheapest place to start is your own outbox. Read your last three client emails as though you were the person paying, and ask:

  • Could they tell from this what they got this month, without opening an attachment?
  • Does anything here explain why a decision was made, or only what was done?
  • If they forwarded it to their CFO, would it help them or embarrass them?

And stop assuming your client has already decided you are not worth the spend. Earn it every day, make it unmistakable to them that you have, and go into the next opportunity with confidence instead of apologies.

See the research
Or take the 2-minute quiz and see if you can name the share of those 400 clients who put “finding a marketing agency we can trust” among their most severe challenges.
Susan

I write with AI as my co-author. The ideas, the advice and the final read are mine.

Get the next one

One surprising finding from our research, every couple of weeks. If a study turns up nothing that contradicts what agency leaders already assume, we skip the issue.